Processing expert assessments
Posted: Sun Jan 19, 2025 3:12 am
Brainstorming is a method of expert assessments, which consists of a group discussion of a problem to generate new ideas or solution options. The key feature of this approach is an active creative search for optimal solutions in particularly difficult situations, when none of the known methods of solving the problem is suitable. Criticism of any ideas that at first glance seem absurd and illogical is strictly prohibited during the discussion.
The session is conducted by a pre-assigned leader. His main function is to manage the course of the discussion in the process of solving the problem under study. Before the session begins, he explains to the participants the essence of the problem, the rules for its discussion, and suggests considering a couple of ideas.
During the brainstorming, the chinese overseas america data package participants are divided into two groups, one of which generates ideas, and the second performs analytical functions. Moreover, it is not at all necessary for the idea generators to be high-level specialists in the field under consideration and confidently navigate the task at hand. When selecting invited specialists, it is necessary to strive to ensure that the group is sufficiently representative, and that people have extensive experience, erudition and imagination.
Brainstorming
Source: shutterstock.com
The duration of the session without a break is about 45 minutes. Each expert is given no more than 2-3 minutes to speak, which can be repeated later. In each speech, the participants in the discussion must put forward as many ideas as possible, as well as develop previous theses. All submitted options must be real and constructive, aimed at solving the problem under discussion. During the formation of ideas, they cannot be criticized directly, but disapproval can be felt in the form of minimal support for the discussion by other participants.
The second stage of brainstorming involves a detailed analysis of the submitted ideas, thoughts and points of view, as a result of which the most valuable and promising solutions are selected. This is done by a group of specialists, who have modern technical means and quantitative analysis methods in their arsenal, as a result of which the final solution is more objective.
At the end of the survey, the expert group processes the results. This is done in order to summarize the information received, which was veiled in a hidden form in the experts' answers. After processing, the following tasks should be solved:
determine the competence of each expert and the generality of the assessment of objects;
construct a generalized ranking of objects;
determine the consistency of opinions of survey participants;
determine the relationship between rankings.
The session is conducted by a pre-assigned leader. His main function is to manage the course of the discussion in the process of solving the problem under study. Before the session begins, he explains to the participants the essence of the problem, the rules for its discussion, and suggests considering a couple of ideas.
During the brainstorming, the chinese overseas america data package participants are divided into two groups, one of which generates ideas, and the second performs analytical functions. Moreover, it is not at all necessary for the idea generators to be high-level specialists in the field under consideration and confidently navigate the task at hand. When selecting invited specialists, it is necessary to strive to ensure that the group is sufficiently representative, and that people have extensive experience, erudition and imagination.
Brainstorming
Source: shutterstock.com
The duration of the session without a break is about 45 minutes. Each expert is given no more than 2-3 minutes to speak, which can be repeated later. In each speech, the participants in the discussion must put forward as many ideas as possible, as well as develop previous theses. All submitted options must be real and constructive, aimed at solving the problem under discussion. During the formation of ideas, they cannot be criticized directly, but disapproval can be felt in the form of minimal support for the discussion by other participants.
The second stage of brainstorming involves a detailed analysis of the submitted ideas, thoughts and points of view, as a result of which the most valuable and promising solutions are selected. This is done by a group of specialists, who have modern technical means and quantitative analysis methods in their arsenal, as a result of which the final solution is more objective.
At the end of the survey, the expert group processes the results. This is done in order to summarize the information received, which was veiled in a hidden form in the experts' answers. After processing, the following tasks should be solved:
determine the competence of each expert and the generality of the assessment of objects;
construct a generalized ranking of objects;
determine the consistency of opinions of survey participants;
determine the relationship between rankings.